Scores tell you whether a page is technically sound. Judging the content (does it persuade, inform, rank for the right things?) takes a little detective work. Bloomlight gives you the instruments; here's the method.
Start with the technical floor
Content can't perform on a broken stage. Before judging the words, make sure the page's SEO findings are clear: title and description present, headings ordered, images described. A page with unresolved basics will underperform no matter how good the copy is. Fix those first so you're evaluating content instead of plumbing.
Read your titles like a stranger
Your page title and description are what people see in search results before they ever reach the content. For each key page ask: would someone who's never heard of us click this? "Home | Meadowbrook Bakery" says little; "Fresh sourdough & custom cakes in Willow Creek" earns the click. Rewrites here are the cheapest content improvement available, and the finding and audit loop confirms them within minutes.
Let the metrics graph judge changes
When you rewrite a page, note the date and watch its metrics graph over the following weeks. Content changes move things slowly (search engines need to re-crawl, visitors need to arrive), so look for a gradual drift rather than a sudden step. No movement after a month is also an answer: that page may need restructuring instead of another polish.
Match the page to a question
Every worthwhile page answers a question someone actually asks. Walk your key pages and name the question each one answers: "what does it cost?", "can I trust them?", "how do I book?". A page that answers nothing in particular is a candidate to merge or cut, and trimming dead weight helps the pages that remain.